Closer/ClaudeReport.md

# Claude QA Report — Full-App QA (living report)

> **Verdict (2026-06-26): 0 open P0–P2 (1 P3 J-OBS). Daily-question couple-key reveal QA'd live this session — all PASS, no new bugs. (Reveal feature now committed: HEAD `e6a8dee`.)**
>
> This report shows **current state only**. Fixed issues live here for **one** confirmation round, then they're pruned
> to the archived-ID line below (full detail stays in git history). See **Report hygiene** in `ClaudeQAPlan.md`.

## Run-state (current)
`R10 (2026-06-26) full ClaudeQAPlan run | Pass A ✅ Pass B ✅ | Pass C in progress | Fixed **E-GAME-002 (P1, user-reported)** game-start push + foreground deep-link | 1 open P2 (C-SEC-001) + 1 P3 J-OBS | Sam premium = ON | NEXT ACTION: continue Pass C families (Messages, Today/reveal, Date/BucketList, Wheel history, AnswerHistory, YourProgress, Paywall, auth/onboarding, light parity); confirm E-GAME-002 next round then prune. Then D–J.`
- **Uncommitted (user commits):** `functions/src/games/onGameSessionUpdate.ts` (DEPLOYED live), `app/.../MainActivity.kt` + `app/.../notifications/PartnerNotificationManager.kt` (E-GAME-002). **+ Foreground game-alert feature (this session, app rebuilt+installed both):** NEW `notifications/GamePromptController.kt`, `ui/components/GamePromptBanner.kt`; edited `core/navigation/AppNavigation.kt`, `core/notifications/AppMessagingService.kt`, `ui/home/HomeScreen.kt`, `ui/home/HomeViewModel.kt`, `ui/wheel/WheelSessionViewModel.kt`. Note: reinstalling the debug APK can leave a stale FCM token until re-register on next launch.
- **Foreground "partner started a game" alert + bold Game Waiting card (R10, user-requested) — DONE+VERIFIED.** When the app is OPEN and a partner starts a game, a prominent **in-app top banner** ("<partner> started <Game>" + Join) slides in (mirrors chat's in-app surface) instead of the easy-to-miss system notification; **Join → joins the game**. Verified live for all 4 session games: banner name correct (Spin the Wheel / This or That / How Well Do You Know Me / Desire Sync); Join → joins wheel (ToT shows graceful "QA is playing a Wheel game" when types mismatch); **suppressed** when already on that game's screen (added `ActiveGameSessionMonitor.enter/leave` to `WheelSessionViewModel` — the others already had it). Home **"Game waiting"** card redesigned as a **bold purple-gradient hero** (glyph + game name + "Join the game"), promoted to top of "Waiting for you", verified **both themes** → tap **joins the specific game** (not the Play-hub fallback). FCM transport on the emulators is flaky (FcmRetry); the banner was exercised via a data-only high-priority send to the partner token (faithful to the deployed payload).
- **Pass C progress (R10):** **Settings family ✅** (dark + Security on light): Settings list, Subscription, Security, Delete account, Notifications all render clean both-relevant-themes; **4 illustrations confirmed in-context** (Security padlock, Delete-account doorway, Quiet-hours moon, + Subscription); back-stack OK (Security/Delete/Notif → BACK → Settings). **Found C-SEC-001 (P2)** — accepter's Recovery phrase disabled + wrong "invite your partner" copy (see Open issues). **Wheel back-stack RE-CHECKED = not a trap:** live wheel session → BACK → spin/setup → BACK → Play hub (2 backs, no dead-end); earlier "stuck" was automation cycling. Leaving mid-wheel leaves a resumable abandoned active session (normal; cleaned). Home ✅ both themes (stale game card gone).
- **6. Spin the Wheel ✅** — spun→Physical Intimacy→session; Sam joined at Q1; both answered 10 (A/B + 1–5 scale + free-text); per-Q You/QA breakdown renders; completed, 0 active. (Helper `wheel_drive.py` handles mixed types; free-text Qs hide "Next" behind IME.)
- **7. Date Match ✅** — swipe deck ("Swiping with Sam/QA"); QA+Sam mutual like → **"It is a match!" modal live**; new match persisted (date_matches 3→4); **swipe action `enc:v1:` at rest** (only swipedAt clear). 
- **Pass B = COMPLETE (R10): all 7 games played end-to-end 2-device, 0 bugs.** 2 observations: CC day-counter desync (Future.md, by-design?) · **WATCH — wheel back-stack:** after finishing Spin-the-Wheel, system-BACK from the results re-enters the completed wheel-session screen (loop), needed an app relaunch to escape. Possibly automation artifact (missed taps) — **recheck deliberately in Pass C nav fuzzing; file if reproducible (P2 back-stack).**
- **5. Memory Lane ✅** — new capsule sealed (3-mo pick) with future open date; **title+content `enc:v1:` at rest** (admin-verified); lists cross-session. Minor cosmetic: "Opens in 2 mo" shown for a 3-month selection (relative-time display nit; not filed).
- **4. Connection Challenges ✅** — Gratitude Week (in-progress from R9): per-day step, "I did it today", "waiting for partner" both-gate, missed-day catch-up ("Pick it back up"), **streak 🔥→2 synced both devices**. UX note (Future.md): "Day N of 7" counter diverges between partners after asymmetric catch-up (QA D4/Sam D3) while streak stays synced — plausibly by-design, non-blocking.
- **Pass B progress (R10):** **1. This or That ✅** — Deep×10 (varied): QA started, Sam joined via Play-hub card (no duplicate, 1 session), both answered 10, results symmetric both devices ("8/10 in sync", per-Q Match labels correct), session→completed, 0 stale. **2. How Well ✅** — QA-subject 5·Quick: QA answered 5 about self, Sam joined as **guesser** (asymmetric join works), predicted 5, score+breakdown render correctly (1/5, ✓/✗ guess→actual incl. scale Q), completed, 0 stale.
- **R10 scratchpad drivers (reuse):** `r10_set_premium.js <QA|Sam> <on|off>` · `rv_gate.js`/`rv_markreveal.js` (raw-API) · `hw_drive.py <serial> <rounds>` (taps first option+Confirm per Q) · `rv_inspect.js`/`rv_sessions.js` (admin reads). Game-option taps: use uiautomator bounds, NOT fixed coords (layouts shift per question; last Q button = "Done →" not "Confirm →").
- **Admin writes:** user authorized this session (2026-06-26) → premium toggle + baseline reset now working. Baseline reset done (0 active sessions; stale 06-24/06-25 answers cleared). Premium toggle: `scratchpad/r10_set_premium.js <QA|Sam> <on|off>`.
- **Pass A ✅ (R10):** neither-premium → Desire Sync shows 🔒 + opens **paywall** ("Go deeper together"); toggled **Sam premium ON** → QA(free) Play hub badge cleared **live** + Desire Sync opens **setup (no paywall)** = couple-shared unlock holds. Code audit: all gates use `CouplePremiumChecker` except `SubscriptionScreen` (by-design own-status) + `DailyQuestionResolver` (per-user premium-question fallback — verify in Pass B/E it doesn't desync the couple's daily Q). Other 7 features share the verified path (R9 enumerated each).
- **Build:** HEAD `e6a8dee` — clean working tree (reveal feature committed: couple-key encryption, read-gated `secure` subdoc, `onAnswerWritten` both-answered copy, `onAnswerRevealed`). Rebuilt + installed on both emulators this session.
- **Daily-reveal QA (2026-06-26, live, both emulators 5554 dark / 5556 light):** **Gate (raw API):** only-1-answered → partner reads metadata 200 but content **403**, non-member **403/403**; both-answered → partners read each other **200/200**, non-member still **403/403**. **At-rest:** answer doc content-free metadata only; content in gated `secure/payload` (`enc:v1:`). **Reveal:** shows the partner's answer **both directions** (the fixed bug) — QA↔Sam. **Pushes:** `onAnswerWritten` fires (both-answered "unlocked ✨" copy is in deployed code); `onAnswerRevealed` fired live (`isRevealed` flip → "notified partner that X opened"). 0 FATAL either device. Today's test answers wiped after; baseline clean. One low-sev robustness note → `Future.md` (reveal `isRevealed` write isn't retried if it fails). Note: stale active wheel session + 06-24/06-25 unrevealed answers are pre-existing test pollution (confound the Home dashboard daily card; not the reveal feature).
- **Devices / accounts:** emulator-5554 = QA (`Y05AKO2IlTPMa0JQW1BiNIM0uzK2`) · emulator-5556 = Sam (`imDjjO…`) · paired, coupleId `Xal3Kw3gjSdn0niERYKJ`, both free (baseline restored).
- **Docs:** Playbook `ClaudeQAPlan.md` · Coverage `ClaudeQACoverage.md` · Ideas `Future.md` `## QA` · Branding `ClaudeBrandingReview.md`.

## Severity board
| Severity | Open | Fixed (pending 1 confirm) |
|---|---|---|
| P0 | 0 | 0 |
| P1 | 0 | **1** |
| P2 | **1** | 0 |
| P3 | **1** | 0 |

## Open issues
| ID | Sev | Area | Description | Repro | Suggested fix | Status |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| E-GAME-002 | P1 | Notifications / games (user-reported, R10) | **Two bugs in the game-start notification flow** (started Spin-the-Wheel; partner on Settings got nothing). **(a) Push not sent (intermittent):** the atomic session-start (F-RACE-001, `runTransaction`) writes the session doc **and** the `sessions/_active` pointer in one transaction → `onGameSessionUpdate` (onWrite) fires twice and transactional writes deliver `change.before == change.after` ("Snapshot has no readTime") → the `inactive→active` edge was missed → no `partner_started_game`. **(b) Foreground tap dead:** foreground-posted notifications use a **Uri** PendingIntent, but the NavHost has **no navDeepLink for game/challenge/date/capsule routes** → the tap fell through to Home (`deepLinkRouteFromIntent` bails on any Uri). | QA start wheel; Sam on Settings → no push (logs: 20:24 fired, no notifyPartner). Foreground tap → stayed/Home. | **(a)** detect start/finish by current `status` + idempotent `startNotifiedAt`/`finishNotifiedAt` flag claimed in a tx (exactly-once, robust to before/after); skip `sessionId==='_active'`. **(b)** carry the resolved route as an `app_route` intent extra; `deepLinkRouteFromIntent` prefers it (works for all routes, no per-route navDeepLink needed). | **Fixed+verified (deployed funcs + app rebuilt/installed). Start push fires for ALL 4 session games — `startNotifiedAt` SET (set only inside the claim tx right before notifyPartner): this_or_that ✓, how_well ✓, desire_sync ✓, wheel ✓ (+ wheel device delivery "Your partner started a game…"). **Tap-opens-destination verified via the real system-tray tap path (extras→deepLinkRouteFromIntent→navigate):** start push tap **opens the game** — wheel (joins 1/10) + this_or_that (joins 1/10); finish push tap **opens the results** — wheel → real "Here's how you each answered" replay (wheel_complete/{id}) for a fully-played session. Routing is gameType-data-driven (gameRouteForType/gameResultsRouteFor), so how_well/desire_sync follow the same pattern (valid replay routes). Also: foreground/cold app_route tap joins wheel. Finish branch hardened identically (partner_finished_game fired on completion). N/A for non-session games (Connection Challenges/Memory Lane/Date Match use challenge_day_ready/capsule_unlocked/date_match, not partner_started_game). Functions deployed live; app + funcs source uncommitted (user commits).** |
| C-SEC-001 | P2 | Security / recovery (Pass C, R10) | The **accepter** partner's Security screen shows the Recovery phrase **disabled** with copy *"Recovery phrase becomes available after you invite your partner"* — but they're **already paired** (they accepted an invite, never "invite"). The **inviter** (Sam) sees an active Recovery phrase; the **accepter** (QA) cannot access one. Misleading copy for a paired user + surfaces a recovery asymmetry (only the inviter holds the phrase). | 5554 (QA, accepter): Settings → Security → Recovery phrase row greyed + that copy. 5556 (Sam, inviter): same screen → Recovery phrase active. | Fix the accepter copy (e.g. "Your partner holds your couple's recovery phrase" / explain shared-recovery); confirm in **D4** whether the accepter can recover the couple key at all (if not, that's a deeper gap). | **Open (P2)** |
| J-OBS | P3 | A11y / touch targets | A few conversation icon-buttons measure **~42–45dp wide** (48dp tall) — single-axis marginal miss of the 48dp target; fully operable. Most controls are 48dp. | Pass J: uiautomator bounds on conversation → 2–3 clickables `<126px` wide. | Bump those icon-buttons to 48dp min (e.g. `Modifier.minimumInteractiveComponentSize()` / `size(48.dp)`). | **Open (P3, non-blocking)** |

## Resolved & confirmed (archived — full detail in git history)
A-001 · A-003 · A-OBS · B-001 · B-002 · B-003 · B-004 · C-CC-001 · C-DS-001 · C-NAV-001 · D-001 · E-001 · E-002 · E-003 · E-OBS · F-OBS · F-RACE-001 · **I-001** · **I-002** — all fixed and re-verified (commits in history; F-RACE-001 re-confirmed R8; **I-001** query→`whereIn(dayKeys)` + **I-002** Long-score→`Number.toInt()`, fixed `ab29f6b`, re-confirmed live R9: 0 outcomes denials/CCE). Pruned per the one-confirmation-round rule. (C-OBS / `outcomes` list / SubscriptionScreen per-user gate = investigated, **not bugs**.)

## Security cornerstone — clean (Pass D, deep dive, Round 7)
- **D1 at-rest:** chat text + `lastMessagePreview` + all 4 game-answer collections (ToT / How Well / Desire Sync / Wheel, both users) + Memory Lane capsules + date-swipe actions = `enc:v1:`. No plaintext content; only metadata in clear.
- **D2/D3 access:** non-member denied **all** reads/writes (raw Firestore REST → 403); real premium write `users/{uid}/entitlements/premium` denied (server-only → **no self-grant**); cross-couple denied.
- **D4 keys:** couple key phrase-wrapped (argon2id); recovery phrase server-blind; `encryptedRecoveryPhrase` wiped on acceptance; plaintext `inviteCode` not exploitable (invite readable only by inviter; no code-encrypted secret persisted).
- **Robustness:** malformed/abusive deep-link intents (unknown type, missing extras, injection/path-traversal) → 0 crash; killed-state cold-start chat deep-link → conversation loads.

## Round history (one line each)
- **Notif→game fix + dark art + QA sweep (2026-06-26, uncommitted).** **E-GAME-001 (P1, FIXED+VERIFIED):** game notifications "led nowhere" — backgrounded/warm taps landed on Home (MainActivity was standard launch mode → `onNewIntent` never delivered the tap's extras → `pendingDeepLink` unset), and even when routed, the game screen showed *setup* instead of joining (one-shot `getActiveSessionForCouple` raced the post-push Firestore sync → returned stale-empty). Fixes: `AndroidManifest` `MainActivity launchMode=singleTop` + `QuestionSessionRepositoryImpl.getActiveSessionForCouple` now SERVER-first (cache fallback). **Verified live:** Sam backgrounded → taps partner_started_game → lands IN the active This-or-That (1/10), joined, no duplicate session; back-stack sane (game→back→Home→back→exit, C-NAV-001 holds). Generic across game types (shared routing + getActiveSession). **Dark-theme art:** 12 `_dark` variants → `drawable-night-nodpi/` (light names) so dark mode auto-swaps; verified live (Security shows the aubergine variant on dark; light unchanged). **QA sweep:** tabs both themes, deep-link back-stack, all 12 illustrations both themes — **0 FATAL**, baseline intact.
- **Brand art drop (2026-06-26) — wired + QA-swept, 0 issues.** All 11 generated illustrations (A1–A12, source gitignored) wired into their screens via shared `EmptyState` + new `BrandIllustration` helper (commits `077a408`→`5868d06`). **Complete both-theme sweep:** in-context dark **and** light verified for Bucket List (A6), Quiet hours (A9), Security (A11), Delete account (A12) — all render as crisp rounded tiles, on-brand, no clipping/contrast issue; A1 (transparent), A3 (banner) + the empty-only states (A2/A4/A5/A8/A10, unreachable on the baseline couple) verified via the debug Art-preview gallery on both themes + the proven shared tile. **0 FATAL/ANR** both devices; baseline intact (0 sessions/outcomes). Process catch: 5556 was on a stale build mid-sweep → reinstalled current, both now on `768f511`. Details in `ClaudeBrandingReview.md`.
- **R9** — clean confirmation round (**0 new findings**): confirmed + pruned I-001/I-002 (0 outcomes denials/CCE on the fixed build); swept deferred Pass C deep/list screens (Answer History, Activity, Bucket List, Date Match/Matches — both themes) + Pass F network (offline cache render + clean reconnect). 0 open P0–P2.
- **R8** — F-RACE-001 re-confirmed + pruned; Passes I (perf) + J (a11y) run; found+fixed+verified **I-001 & I-002** (outcomes read: query rules-denied + Long/Int parse CCE → "Your Progress" was silently dead). 0 open P0–P2.
- **R7** — multi-angle security/concurrency deep dive → cornerstone fully clean; F-RACE-001 found + fixed + verified. 0 new open.
- **R6** — branding drop + Future.md backlog regression (white-keyhole icons/loader/splash, inclusive gender, copy, rate-limit split, results-push suppression, paywall retry/offline) → 0 new open.
- **R5** — Cloud Functions deployed (E-OBS channel fix, E-003 results routing) + new Pass G (account creation / fake-account abuse) clean → 0 open.
- **R1–R4** — baseline Passes A–F report-only; every P0–P2 found was fixed + verified (see archived IDs).

## Operational constants
- **Execution mode:** autonomous run-to-completion — don't stop; fix blockers inline; cycle fix→re-QA until flawless. Don't hand back when context fills — re-read this run-state + coverage after any compaction. Commit before interruptible work; recover stuck sessions via the session-start ritual.
- **Standing authorization (user, 2026-06-24):** may `firebase deploy --only firestore:rules` + has admin access (Firestore reads/writes/seeds + entitlement toggles) — run without pausing. Only the macOS requirement for iOS (Parts 2/3) is a hard stop.
- **Hardening backlog → Future.md:** App Check not enforced on Firestore; `users/{uid}` update rule allows arbitrary non-`hasPremium` fields (tighten to a field allowlist).